Where is the best ice cream shop in Northern Westchester? You decide.


Photo by Somben Chea from Pexels

We all scream for it. But do we all agree on it? Is there one best place for ice cream in our area? The North Salem Post is on a mission to find out, but first we need your help. We’re inviting our readers to vote for the very best ice cream spot in Northern Westchester.

We’ve done a little bit of legwork for you, narrowing down the options to a sweet six. Our criteria: no national chains, must be full of charm, and nothing more than a 20-minute drive from North Salem. Here, we present the contenders:

  • King Kone (Katonah)
  • Ridgefield Ice Cream Shop (Ridgefield)
  • Blue Bird Ice Cream (Cross River)
  • Red Rooster (Brewster)
  • Deborah Ann’s Sweet Shoppe (Ridgefield)
  • Frank’s Pizzeria (Croton Falls)

Now, here’s what we need you to do: click HERE to vote for your favorite. You can vote now or do some research (see also: hit up all the ice cream spots) and then come back and vote. Polls close Sunday, August 8 at midnight. We’ll announce our winner on Monday, August 9.


I'm interested
I disagree with this
This is unverified